the rehuman what was the purpose of the magna carta? an analysis of the principles of globalization branding case study branding case study apa editing services thesis portal canada

5 proprietary alternatives that are just better.

I’ve been seeing a lot of “open source alternative” lists on digg, slashdot, dzone, etc… recently. You know the kind. “Top 5 open source alternatives to popular proprietary software”. The vast majority of these lists have about a 50% hit rate. The misses, as I consider them to be, don’t have any real advantage to the end-user, they’re just compatible with a philisophical attitude you happen to have.

I think it’s time someone took a stand. Some software is worth paying for. Most of us are never going to look at the source code anyway. And having a dedicated staff who gets 8 hours a day to devote to this software, and is actually held accountable in some fashion if that software sucks, can often actually lead to a good product.

So, in no particular order, here’s my list of 5 solid, awesome, insert-buzzword-here closed source applications that I use instead of any (F)OSS alternatives.

1) “Trillian”:http://www.ceruleanstudios.com
(F)OSS alternatives: “Pidgin”:http://www.pidgin.im , “Adium”:http://www.adiumx.com
Trillian got off to a rocky start back in the day- Mostly due to IM services griping and trying to shield their protocols from third-party apps. You know the story, the ships got smarter, the electronic thumbs got smarter… But it’s really an amazing peice of software. And the plugin community has vastly more useful add-ons than Pidgin or Adium. My main gripes against the other two- Pidgin (formerly GAIM) has a hate on for cygwin libraries I already have installed on my laptop- Even getting around that, the UI just… I felt Pidgin was working against me instead of with me. Adium is fantastic, and I consider it a close runner up. But, sadly, Adium isn’t (yet) available for Windows. Which brings us to the next item on my list.

2) “Windows”:http://www.microsoft.com/windows/
(F)OSS alternatives: Roughly 14 bajillion flavors of linux and unix, OS X (well, sort of, and not anymore).
Look, I could write an entirely seperate entry on this one. The convenience of a pre-install, the hardware support, the software communities, the lack of inferiority complex and fanaticism running rampant among it’s users… I’ll admit it. I have a dual-boot laptop, and I love fiddling around with Gentoo. That doesn’t mean I’d wish it (or even Ubuntu) on my mom if she had things she needed to get done. And since they still won’t let you build a computer and stick OS X on it (hacking aside), the pricepoint for value for a Mac of any flavor tends to run too high. That’s not to say I don’t LIKE OS X- It’s awesome, and it’s the only proof I’ve ever seen that unix is ready for the average user on the desktop- But if I can’t control where I put it, I don’t want it.

3) “TextPad”:http://www.textpad.com
(F)OSS alternatives: “Kate”:http://www.kate-editor.org/ , SciTE , Notepad++ , a slew of others (Context, PSPad, oh, how the list forever grows!)
TextPad is not an IDE, it’s a programmer’s text editor. It’s also good enough to be a notepad replacement. Regex search/replace, syntax highlighting, plugin functionality, and the great grand-daddy of them all, external tool support. My inability to replace this application with something open-source is one of the things that kept me from moving over to linux. I mean it, I really love TextPad __that much__. Mostly, because you can add your own compilers/runtimes quickly and easily. Want to compile your java app? ctrl+1. Want to run it? ctrl+3. And you can add as many as you have installed on your machine. Ruby, Perl, Python, whatever you want. I think I have like 5 different languages ready to compile and run, and it’ll even capture the output for you and show it as a document. I was a little verbose in emphasizing that I’m not a windows FANATIC, per-se, just a fan who believes it’s best for his personal style… That’s not the case here. I’m a textpad fanatic. I really am.

4) “iTunes”:http://www.apple.com/itunes/
(F)OSS alternatives: “Amarok”:http://amarok.kde.org/ , XMMP , “Songbird”:http://www.songbirdnest.com/
I resisted iTunes forever. I really did. I always loved winamp, it still holds a special place in my heart. And when I had to download new versions of Quicktime, I specifically sought out the download file that didn’t have a bundled iTunes. I didn’t own an ipod, and didn’t want to buy music (I’d already transferred all my CD’s to MP3, and on top of that… Yes, fine, I admit that at one point in my life, I used napster on a college network.) when I already had thousands of songs. I tried other stuff… But XMMP is just a winamp clone. Songbird is like iTunes but less functional and more confusing. And Amarok, while pretty cool, just doesn’t have the organizational power. I needed something that could search and organize thousands of songs. Multiple playlists. Smart playlists. Moving things BETWEEN playlists. Sorting by whatever the hell you want. Not to mention, braindead easy subscription to podcasts made life much more entertaining. And yes, I have an iPod now, and I purchase music. And I’m going to pay 30 cents extra per song to get all the DRM removed. Why? Because, let’s face it, I already know the songs I want, and none of them are on eMusic.

5) “Microsoft Office”:http://www.microsoft.com/office
(F)OSS Alternatives: “Open Office”:http://www.openoffice.org/
OpenOffice is a bit of a conundrum to me. There’s so much griping about how Microsoft Office is slow, bloated, and unstable. So someone went and wrote an alternative in Java, essentially making it slower, more bloated, less stable, and with about the same inter-application document consistency as loading up the Acid Test on IE and Firefox. And people were like, “Woo, Office is Dead! Long Live OpenOffice, it’s so much better!” No it isn’t, but I’ll give you this much- It’s price point is __way__ more fair, and instead of pumping it full of features and digging it’s claws into the underlying OS, they’re actively working on making the overall application better, and they’ve done an excellent job of bringing document format standardization into public awareness. I really do think OpenOffice will make an EXCELLENT application, better than the Microsoft equivalent, a full version or two from now. It’s just not there yet, and as fans of quality software, we really need to suck it up and recognize that.

None of this, by the way, is meant to imply that I __prefer__ propriety software to open-source applications. What I’m trying to say is that end-users owe it to themselves to be a little more agnostic about the matter, and when they size up the quality of a product, they should be looking more at the software, and less at the license. As a matter of fairness, I’ll fire off a couple of open source apps that I consider brilliant, indispensable, and unequaled by anything else out there under any license.

“Paint.NET”:http://www.getpaint.net is somewhere between MS Paint and Photoshop. Power, ease of use, easily updatable, you can edit photos or draw stick figures with this thing, whatever your heart desires.

“Firefox”:http://www.mozilla.org/firefox is really just the best browser I’ve ever used. IE 7 was a very impressive improvement (Oh, come on. Admit it.) But it’s still playing catchup.

“7-Zip”:http://www.7-zip.org recently beat out winrar as my archiver of choice. It uses more memory during intensive operations, but the compression ratios are amazing, the speed is quite impressive, and honestly, the UI is so good that you don’t even notice you’re using the application, all you’re thinking about is what you’re getting done.

Hope you enjoyed the list. Feel free to comment if I left anything out.

-Alex

If you enjoyed this post, please consider to leave a comment or subscribe to the feed and get future articles delivered to your feed reader.

Comments

For instant messaging, I really like Kopete.

OS X, is not free, nor is it open-source

Finally, the only closed-source software that I prefer over open-source is probably Picasa (even though I loved kPhotoAlbum)

Man, you’re sticking your neck out :) Good on you for producing this list, I can feel the flames coming your way soon though.

I agree with most of your list – my colleague here at work is also a TextPad fanatic, I personally prefer PHP Designer 2007 but that’s because I’m a pure PHP coder.

Additions – no matter how much the F/OSS people claim it is, there is no way in hell that the GIMP is better than Photoshop. I’ve given the GIMP a good shot at proving me wrong, but I’m sorry, it’s just not ready.

Come to think of it, that’s the only addition I can think of :)

Have you realised that *NIX systems are not at all an alternative to windows? I’ve never been able to do under windows all my dev work i do on myfavourite distro, and apart for playing games windows is no good to me (and it now comes in a new flavor, the slow-your-cpu-with-vista’ xperience)

Well i wont go on any longer seeing the trollish-type message it is…

and by the way, do you know about TextMate on OSX? i think it _is_ actually the best proprietary editor, even if my personnal taste would bettter go to emacs, which i can really tune the way i like even more than mates.

I would like to add Parallels (or VMWare) – Could never have lived without it, on Windows or the Mac.

Great post!

I personally prefer Miranda over Trillian & Vim over Textpad.
But I also prefer Opera over Firefox, x2plorer over ?, Office over OpenOffice.
And I do agree that FOSS is not always the best option.
As an end user I do not differentiate between FOSS and a proprietary but free solution.

As much as I hate to admit it, in some aspects you are right. I haven’t used trillian and textpad and I gave iTunes a try but I still stick with Winamp, XMMS and Amarok but in regards to Windows I do have to admit you have a point. I have been an Ubuntu user for almost 2 years now, but I believe it still has a lot to go until it can be a good alternative to Windows. Don’t get me wrong, I appreciate the extraordinary evolution and adoption they had since they started and I simply love their goals and philosophy, but until games and hardware companies start supporting Linux we still have a long road ahead, and these are just to name a few. The problem is that normal users don’t want geeky stuff, but such things can still be found in Ubuntu, however less and less with each of their releases, so kudos to them, I hope they keep it up.
With OpenOffice.org I had a different experience, I am currently using it both on Windows and on Linux and I am happy with how it works, for the usual stuff I do, like keeping some simple sheets and writing a few documents, it’s just great and it is not even that slow.

For me its Lightroom (or similar raw photo developer), which is a very large reason why i use Windows as my desktop.

Re. TextPad. I’ve used TextPad extensively so I think I can confidently point out a better, open-source alternative: jEdit (http://www.jedit.org/). It has all the features you mentioned about TextPad with the possible exception of external tool support (I simply haven’t looked for that feature in it, and it may well have it). Tons of plugins, syntax highlighting, powerful searching, great file browsing model (better than TextPad’s), code completion, AND it’s cross-platform.

Given that I have to develop on Windows, Mac and Linux machines because I work in various places, being able to use the same text editor everywhere is a huge bonus for me.

Don’t get me wrong, TextPad is nice, but I think jEdit is at least as good. But hey, to each his own for this kind of stuff.

Oracle

Sorry to say that, but apart from the actual features of the database, the tools for management, analysis, troubleshooting etc are lightyears ahead any (F)OSS alternatives.

you’re list is accurate, very so. The only additions i can think of are the creation tools (Photoshop, Illustrator, PageMaker, Quark, sound tools, video editing…). There really aren’t as good free solutions to these problems.

However, free software is mostly aimed at developers, sys admins, people who actually know a thing or two about computer in general. And in that it excels.

But for creation/design, its not even close (yes, Gimp sucks).

Please stop spreading the rumors that OpenOffice.Org is written in Java (it’s not). I’m a big Java fan, especially since it pays my bills, but let’s be accurate here. There are some optional components of oOo that use Java (specifically the database), but the core system is C++. Even these components are native compiled on modern linux distros using gcj.

I could write list called “Five people that are better than five other people” and it would have as much validity. I mean, kudos for your opinion, man, and if this works for you then rock on, but this is purely subjective. You don’t even define what “just better” means.

Windows? I’ve got five boxes running Ubuntu. To hell with Windows’ lack of a reasonable command line, binary bias, cruft-gathering registry, idiotic update “validation” utilties, once-yearly (if you’re lucky) service packs … ugh. Yes, there are some things Windows does extremely well. But “just better” than *nix? I wouldn’t even know what you mean.

Textpad? I realize that text editors are a religious choice among programmers, but, dude … Textpad? Among its “features” are listed, “It can handle file sizes up to the limits of virtual memory” and “Text can be in either the ANSI (Windows) or OEM (DOS) code sets”. Whoop-de-freakin’-do. I’ve used Textpad and, I’m not sorry to say bud, but you and I get into a debate on the merits of Textpad vs., oh, Vim, and the only point you’re going to have is learning curve issues. After that, I win every point. Every one. All of them. All the points. You lose. I win.

Of your other choices the only one I can unqualifyingly agree with is iTunes, which delivers a set of highly desirable proprietary services. Trillian *is* great software and I also like Microsoft Office, but you’d need to define your criteria for “better” before I’d absolutely agree. Otherwise you’re not saying anything meaningful beyond, hey, “I like these!”

Okay. Hey. I like chocolate ice cream. It’s the best of all the other flavors.

Oracle – ugh!

The only product the company makes that is even reasonably acceptable is the RDB and that is an overcomplicated monster that takes far more trouble than it is worth to keep running. If you really need it’s power, then you might be stuck with it. For 99% of the rest of us, DB2, PostgreSQL, SqlServer, MySql, probably even Derby are better choices. I don’t hate Oracle as a company, but I *HATE* their products.

Oracle Portal – absolute garbage
Oracle AS – functional, but not nearly as good as WebLogic
TopLink – can’t even compare to Hibernate
JDeveloper – bloated mess. NetBeans is *so* much better.

It’s not entirely clear what point you’re trying to make. I use open source and commerical software, as do many other developers I know, but my choices differ from yours. Here’s some:

2) Who’s the developer? You or your mother? For development, Linux is a much better platform, and, like you, I could write a separate article about this. Read this: http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2007/02/drm_in_windows.html

3) Ever heard of commerical SlickEdit? Runs on your buddy Windows and *Nix. Bragging about a product that has a built in keystroke to compile a Java source file is an odd argument.

5) Get your facts right. Open office is not written in Java, and the fact that you think it is shows that you don’t know a lot about open source. Most open source groups didn’t look too kindly on Java until Sun open sourced the JDK. They certainly would not have promoted an office suite written in Java. On the point of usability, I use Open Office at home and use MS Office at work under duress. I’m happy with OO as it is.

As far as I am concerned, iTunes is horrible. Thrice I have tried it, each time on a different machine. It has yet to actually work without causing noticable lag on my machine. Personally, I play everything in VLC – sure it may not have the best interface, but that thing will play just about any media file you have.

As far as text files go: wordpad/write in Windows, and vi in *NIX.

On the topic of ease of use, I’d say you haven’t given Ubuntu a proper run. I loved it because the live CD not only let me try the system, but allowed me to use and configure the system while still installing it. It means I didn’t have to wait out the installer before I got right into using it.

On the matter of Office suites, Microsoft Office if it is already installed, OpenOffice otherwise, simply because I’m too lazy to dig out my Office install disk.

Haley…

awesome blog keep updating and you will see us comming back and back….

Suggestion :
Video/Edit – Vegas Video
– Light, stable
– Support many practical audio/video codecs
– Only 110 dollars
– Quick to learn
– Dragg and drop feature
– Zounds of effects
– Etc.

Mac is actually attaining actually as well as increasing number of consumers. In fact the part Macintosh computer entrepreneurs reached close to 20% of final amount of US notebook computer owners. Without a doubt a great job for a company once nearly removed from computer market. However the issue is always that increase in number of Macintosh end users is a good reason for the actual quick boost from the variety of software designed for Macs personal computer system. To select amongst these sensibly you need to proceed through and focus carefully.

apidexin for $39.99

There are definitely a variety of particulars like that to take into consideration. That may be a nice level to convey up. I supply the ideas above as common inspiration however clearly there are questions just like the one you convey up the place an important factor shall be working in trustworthy good faith. I don?t know if greatest practices have emerged round issues like that, however I’m positive that your job is clearly recognized as a good game. Each girls and boys really feel the influence of only a second�s pleasure, for the remainder of their lives.

An interesting dialogue is worth comment. I think that you need to write extra on this topic, it might not be a taboo topic however generally people are not sufficient to talk on such topics. To the next. Cheers

An attention-grabbing discussion is price comment. I believe that you must write more on this subject, it may not be a taboo subject but typically persons are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers

There are certainly a number of details like that to take into consideration. That is a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith. I don?t know if best practices have emerged around things like that, but I am sure that your job is clearly identified as a fair game. Both boys and girls feel the impact of just a moment�s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.

You made some respectable factors there. I seemed on the web for the difficulty and located most people will go together with together with your website.

I�d should verify with you here. Which is not something I often do! I take pleasure in reading a publish that may make individuals think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!

Typically the global range of motion remedies really are a least expensive opportinity for visitors to remain attached in their holiday offshore. Using least expensive options, you will discover more gains with global SIM greeting cards which might be titled concern. Look into the huge benefits just before making use of SIM assistance.

Follow me on Forums and on Instagram (@ezyville) be certain check out and like the Examiner Shoes Facebook page as well as the subscribe to each of Youtube channel which is full of up-dates and commentary you will not see here.

It’s amazing to pay a visit this website and reading the views of
all colleagues about this article, while I am also zealous of getting knowledge.

Thanks for finally writing about >5 proprietary alternatives that are just better.
| Callng Shotgun <Loved it!

Hello, yup this post is truly pleasant and I have learned lot of things from it on the topic of blogging.
thanks.

The media for downloading has never been this fast and
simple as it is now. With close to this much controversy clinging
to its name, it will come as no real surprise that several in the world’s law enforcement authorities have
been looking for ways to shut it down for good. Trading invites
numerous sites is extremely frowned upon within the exclusive Bit – Torrent community since it allows anti-piracy groups to infiltrate private trackers with less effort.

You’re so interesting! I do not believe I’ve read through something like this before.

So nice to discover another person with some genuine thoughts on this issue.
Seriously.. thanks for starting this up. This site is something that is needed on the internet, someone with a bit of originality!

Excellent post. I used to be checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed!

Extremely useful info specially the remaining phase :) I handle such information much.

I was looking for this certain information for a very
long time. Thanks and best of luck.

I was excited to discover this post. I wanted
to appreciate it for your time due to this extremely
nice study! ! I totally prized almostt every a member of it and i also do
you have saved as a most favorite to look at new gadgets inside the online business.

When you compare these statistics with previous years’ data – 237 reported piracy
attacks in 2011 and 75 in 2012 – there’s little doubt left that this menace of
piracy at the very least off the coast of Somalia looks like it’s on a sharp decline.
The creation of Dish Network portals has reduced the price of satellite TV channels
greatly. Measure adjustments to the activity of your competitors before
five years.

What’s up Dear, are you genuinely visiting this web site daily, if so afterward you will
absolutely take pleasant experience.

Leave a comment